In the Ningde era, China Chuangxin Airlines applied for enforcement because it did not make a public apology, and the execution target was 2221980 yuan. The case was filed on April 21, 2025, and the cause of the case was unfair competition disputes.
According to the announcement of the Changsha Intermediate Court of the Executive Court on June 5, in the case of unfair competition disputes between the plaintiff Ningde Times and the defendant Zhongchuang Xinhang,
the civil judgment of the Hunan Provincial High Court held that the act of Zhongchuang Xinhang issuing the Statement on its official WeChat public number on July 27, 2022 constituted commercial defamation. In the
judgment, Innovation Airlines shall, within 15 days from the effective date of the judgment, publicly apologize on its official website and the public number of the WeChat, and retain it in the above-mentioned media for at least 15 days. The feud
between Ningde Times and China Chuangxin Airlines has a long history. In January 2025 alone, China Chuangxin Airlines announced three prosecution cases in Ningde Times.
On June 13, the first trial of the dispute over the infringement of technical secrets between China Innovation Airlines and Ningde Times will be held.